patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Pedestrians First

Our city grid and pedestrian-oriented businesses are ideally suited for walking, but our traffic culture isn't yet.

 

In our hierarchy of transportation in the city, there is none more basic, fundamental and sustainable than walking. Not to mention, at the end of any trip, no matter how else you got to your destination, everyone becomes a pedestrian at some point in their journey.

According to our traffic laws, the pedestrian has the right of way when crossing. However, in practice, many drivers do not respect this right. Also, they'll often encroach upon the pedestrian so closely that it startles and strikes fear, or worse.

(Go here for a list of pedestrian deaths in Santa Monica since 2001.)

In a sign that some things have not changed much, Disney perhaps best parodied this conflict with the 1950 animated short Motor Mania. The film highlights the Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde-like nature of people who are perfectly civil folks on foot but become a menace to pedestrians, like they just were, once behind they are behind wheel.

I’ve been known most for my advocacy for bicycling, but I do a lot of walking to get around as well. I feel very strongly that we need to do more to improve pedestrian safety and comfort.

I walk into downtown Santa Monica when I’m not in a hurry. I walk to get groceries. I walk to the bus stop when traveling Hollywood or downtown L.A. And sometimes, I make my 2-mile work commute on foot instead of riding my bike. I’ve even done a few epic urban walking events, like The Great Los Angeles Walk, walking along the entire length of Wilshire Blvd. from one end in downtown L.A. to other end at the St. Monica Statue.

Like most people who spend anytime walking in the L.A. area—which, contrary to popular belief and Missing Persons lyrics from the '80s, is actually a pretty substantial demographic—I’ve learned firsthand how little respect pedestrians get at times.

Santa Monica is certainly ahead of many other cities in Southern California in fostering a walkable environment, and this is reflected in our high ranking by the Web site WalkScore.com (#4 for the state). However, this walkability ranking is largely the product of our coherent street grid, diverse range of local businesses within walking distance and ample transit connections—not necessarily because walking is safer here.

Santa Monica also ranks #1 out of 104 cities of similar size in the state on the California Office of Traffic Safety for pedestrian deaths and injuries. (We’re also #1 in our population class for bicycle and motorcycle injuries and deaths as well.)

In fairness for comparison, and as local-law enforcement representatives will point out, Santa Monica has more traffic of all kinds than many similar-size cities, in part because of so many visitors who boost our non-resident population. However, I’m not interested in making excuses for our injury and death rates—I’m more interested in a culture change that can bring those numbers down. The string of recent collisions involving pedestrians in Santa Monica should underline the urgency of the situation.

Creating safer streets is not a change that will come easily, and we all are collectively responsible. It’s going to require drivers to slow down (speed limits are not suggestions) and put down the cell phones. In an ideal world, drivers will be courteous and cautious around those on foot as they are required to by law. But since that is clearly not the case yet, pedestrians need to be very alert and not presume drivers will always yield even if the pedestrain has the right of way.

Law enforcement needs to get more serious about defending our most vulnerable road users and stage more crosswalk stings. We need to reform the laws and judicial system to take driving crimes seriously, instead of wrist-slaps and getting reckless drivers back behind the wheel again as soon as possible. Transportation engineers need to reflect the vital role of pedestrians in compact cities and stop placing safety considerations so far below the concern for vehicle speed and throughput.

Santa Monica has been making some positive changes over the years, including some traffic-calming measures and medians that make crossing easier, among other things. That's certainly more than can be said for a lot of our neighbors. However, our abysmal rankings by the Office of Traffic Safety clearly suggest these measures have not gone far enough considering our high level of foot traffic.

As an advocate for bicycling improvements, I think it’s also important to point out here that many of the safety measures advocated for improving bike safety, like bike lanes, result in improved safety for all street users. As Transportation Planning Manager Lucy Dyke has mentioned at several meetings concerning the pending bike plan, the reconfiguration of Ocean Park Blvd. reduced traffic collisions of all kinds, not just those involving bikes, by about half.

Our physical environment is only half of the equation, though. We have to develop a culture of safety and a culture of respect for our most vulnerable street users. To me, one of the clearest ways to distinguish right and wrong when it comes to interacting with pedestrians, whether it be in a car or on a bike, is if I cause alarm to the pedestrian, I’m doing it wrong.

I see people run across crosswalks sometimes like they are a gazelle surrounded by lions, or waiting at a curb endlessly, desperate for someone to finally yield. This is all backward, not only according to our laws, but our values as a city.

Walking is essential for us all in getting around, and our heavy foot traffic drives our local business as well. We need to put the pedestrian and their safety concerns first and really mean it. I love walking all over this town, but I’d also like to survive long enough to continue doing so for a long time to come.

About this column: Environmentally friendly living in the city by the sea. Related Topics: Pedestrian, Pedestrian Safety, Safety, Traffic, and Walking

Marie

8:19 am on Monday, August 8, 2011

Both driving and walking are hazardous in Santa Monica because of the allowance of right hand turns on red. Doing away with right on red would greatly improve conditions.

Reply

Gary Kavanagh

9:48 am on Monday, August 8, 2011

Right on does red create a lot of hazards, especially when drivers do not stop before turning as they are supposed to under law. Especially at intersections with steady pedestrian traffic, I would agree right turns on red should be prohibited.

Reply

Andrew Hoyer

11:14 am on Monday, August 8, 2011

This can be a very touchy subject sometimes. I fully agree that drivers can be very obtuse in their actions towards pedestrians. I've lived in Los Angeles for over eight years now in a few different neighborhoods and as someone who walks and rides a bike but still drives over 15K miles a year for work, I've observed this issue from all sides.

In their attitudes towards pedestrians, LA drivers are probably the worst I've seen. For some reason, even though they are turning left and must wait for the light to turn green many dirvers feel a need to pull into the crosswalk while they idle. Not only does this intimidate pedestrians but it also makes it difficult for the driver who wants to turn right on red to see past them into traffic so they creep farther forward as well.

Reply

Andrew Hoyer

11:19 am on Monday, August 8, 2011

But I can also say that just as drivers get upset at bicyclists who ignore traffic rules by running stop lights, etc. I've witnessed countless pedestrians who enter the crosswalk long after the the don't walk sign has started blinking. In areas like the Vermont and Western Avenue corridors this can tie up the flow of traffic significantly as drivers patiently wait for their opportunity to turn right on a green light. In situations like these turning right on a red light is sometimes the only way that traffic can keep flowing.

I don't think that we will ever be able to separate pedestrians from drivers so this dichotomy will continue. The best solution that I can imagine will occur when we finally summon the political will to vastly improve LA's public transportation infrastructure which will hopefully have the effect of reducing the number of cars on the road.

Reply

Marilyn Belknap

12:18 pm on Monday, August 8, 2011

I live in Santa Monica and am amazed at how pedestrians just walk out in the middle of the street without even checking for oncoming cars and just expect cars to stop on a dime for them. Also, I've seen pedestrians crossing on the red and just stroll along in the crosswalk talking on their cell phone completely not caring that their holding up traffic. In fact, I think some of them enjoy the fact that they are. So please don't blame the driver because I'd say that fault it's a 50-50.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Gary Kavanagh

12:37 pm on Monday, August 8, 2011

There are people who do not take enough care when walking, but all road users are responsible to the safety of everyone else. Drivers, who are capable of the most harm to others, must be especially careful. In some areas of Santa Monica, walking traffic is very frequent, and as such, drivers need to slow down and be mindful, and that includes being aware of pedestrians looking to cross, and considering the possibility of the less predictable as well.

I am a very alert walker, I make eye contact and wait for open moments to begin crossing, and at controlled intersections I wait for crossing signal. My wife does the same. Yet we are both frequently alarmed by drivers who wait until the last possible moment to slow, or inch into our space, swerve around instead of stopping, all actions which are rude, dangerous, and illegal.

I believe everyone needs to be more responsible and safe, including pedestrians and bicyclists, however since it the automobile that is the deadly force on the road, I do believe the greatest responsibility for life rests with careful and prudent driving. In cities and countries with far better traffic safety than our own, there are far greater penalties and responsibilities for vehicle operators, especially in cases involving more vulnerable road users. Bicyclists in such places are also held accountable for harm if they hit a pedestrian, since it is the walker who is considered the most vulnerable.

Leave a comment